Managing conflict between high performers requires early intervention, clear expectations, and a willingness to make hard decisions.
Managing conflict between high performers is one of the most important jobs a leader has, and pretending it will go away is not a management strategy.
One of the more difficult situations you can face as the owner of an architecture, engineering, or environmental consulting firm is having two of your best people who simply can’t stand each other. Both are talented, productive, and important to the business. And both seem to think the other one is either an idiot or a jerk, or both.
Welcome to management! Your first instinct may be to bang their heads together like coconuts and tell them to grow up. I understand the temptation. You have clients to serve, projects to deliver, and a business to run. You really don’t have time to referee a personality contest between two otherwise intelligent adults.
But their inability to get along affects everyone around them. Employees take sides, communication breaks down, meetings become uncomfortable, and decisions that should take five minutes take five days. Pretty soon, you have two separate camps in your organization, complete with their own supporters and competing versions of history. You are running an AEC firm, not a middle school cafeteria.
Here are my thoughts:
-
Don’t pretend it will fix itself. The first mistake many firm leaders make is hoping the problem will disappear. They tell themselves these two people are professionals and will eventually work things out. They might even convince themselves that a little healthy competition is good for the business. It isn’t healthy competition when people are actively trying to undermine one another, and it rarely gets better with time alone.
Step in early. Don’t wait until someone resigns, a client gets caught in the crossfire, or somebody sends an email copying 14 people to explain why the other person is incompetent. By then, you have a much bigger problem. -
Figure out what’s really going on. Before playing marriage counselor, figure out what is behind the conflict. Sometimes it is a genuine personality clash. One person is analytical and deliberate while the other is impatient and action-oriented. Sometimes it is a turf war, a disagreement over credit, or a legitimate performance issue nobody has been willing to address. And sometimes one person really is behaving badly.
Talk to them separately. Ask questions and listen carefully. Don’t automatically believe the first person who arrives with a 21-slide PowerPoint presentation documenting the other person’s shortcomings. You need facts, not a prosecuting attorney. -
Make professional behavior a non-negotiable. You don’t have to make people like each other. You do have to make them work together. I don’t expect everyone in a firm to be best friends, go to dinner together, or spend weekends riding motorcycles. But I do expect them to communicate, share information, respect each other’s responsibilities, and put the interests of the firm ahead of personal grievances.
Be direct about what needs to change. No undermining, withholding information, gossiping, or recruiting other employees to join their personal war. You are paying them to do a job, not organize a political action committee. -
Put them closer together. Here is a tactic I have actually used: Move their offices closer together. Maybe even put them in the same room. I know that sounds counterintuitive, but physical separation can make the problem worse. They communicate through email instead of talking, avoid each other in the hallway, and use other employees as messengers. A minor disagreement becomes a major diplomatic incident.
Putting people closer together can encourage direct communication and make it harder to turn every minor issue into a formal dispute. They may even discover that the other person isn’t quite as awful as they imagined. Obviously, this isn’t appropriate in cases involving harassment, bullying, or a serious power imbalance. But for mutual friction between two capable professionals, it is worth trying. -
Don’t reward bad behavior just because someone’s valuable. Some firm leaders tolerate outrageous behavior from high performers because they are afraid of losing them. A rainmaker gets a pass for being abusive. A brilliant technical person gets to treat everyone else like they’re stupid. A project manager makes life miserable for an entire department because nobody wants to risk losing their production capacity.
That is a terrible precedent. Your other employees are watching. When you tolerate bad behavior from your most valuable people, you are telling everyone else that your stated values and standards don’t really mean much. Don’t be surprised when your other good people start looking for somewhere else to work. - Be prepared to make a hard decision. Sometimes you can fix these situations, and sometimes you can’t. If one person refuses to change, you may have to move them into a different role, change their reporting relationship, or ultimately let them go. Keeping two people who are poisoning the culture can cost you much more than losing one of them.
Your job isn’t to keep everyone happy. It is to build an organization where good people can do good work, clients are well served, and the business makes money. You cannot let two people hold the entire organization hostage because they don’t like each other. If they cannot figure out how to work together professionally, you may have to figure out how to work without one of them.
After all, you run an AEC firm. You didn’t sign up to run a dysfunctional family reunion every Monday morning.
![]() |
Mark Zweig is consultant at SNZweig. Contact him at mzweig@snzweig.com. |
